Who is the best player ever to play?

Discussion in 'Football Card Talk' started by pcag, Aug 20, 2009.

  1. pcag

    pcag New Member

    Who is the best player to ever play in the NFL?

    Name your top 5 of all time
     
  2. ac-n-mike

    ac-n-mike New Member

    in NO particular order... and remember I am a NBA guy... NOT a NFL guy...

    JIM BROWN
    JOE MONTANA
    JERRY RICE
    WALTER PAYTON
    BARRY SANDERS

    ITS A TOUGH 5.... CAUSE UNITAS, BAUGH, LT, NITCHZKE AND A FEW OTHERS ARE GOOD ARGUMENTS AS WELL
     
  3. HiEnd

    HiEnd New Member

    Jim Brown
    Lawrence Taylor
    Walter Payton
    Joe Montana
    John Elway
     
  4. ac-n-mike

    ac-n-mike New Member

    you GOTTA have Jerry Rice in the top 5... thats against the law isn't it? LOL
     
  5. HiEnd

    HiEnd New Member

    Thought about that,but the problem was,who comes out.

    LT has to be there. He's arguably the greatest defensive player ever.

    Montana and Elway to me are 1 & 1a for the greatest QB's ever,and Sweetness/Jim Brown speak for themselves
     
  6. Pee632

    Pee632 New Member

    I would say
    Gale Sayers
    Jerry Rice
    Brett Farve
    Lawrence Taylor
    & Sweetness it should have been 10
     
  7. iLikePie

    iLikePie New Member

    in no order...

    jerry rice
    walter payton
    brett favre
    barry sanders
    lawrence taylor
     
  8. tigsfan

    tigsfan New Member

    Moving this from the IP discussion area to the football area...
     
  9. pcag

    pcag New Member

    mine in order is

    Jim Brown
    lawrence taylor
    Jerry Rice
    Joe Montana
    Barry Sanders
     
Draft saved Draft deleted
Similar Threads: best player
Forum Title Date
Football Card Talk Who is the Best Players By Jersey #? Jul 12, 2007
Football Card Talk Who will be the best player in the NFL Draft??? Aug 2, 2006
Football Card Talk Who Will Be The Best QB Out of the 2nd Year Guys? Jul 4, 2013
Football Card Talk The BEST blaster of chrome ever! (Cam) Feb 10, 2012
Football Card Talk Who is the best team in the NFL going into Week 8? Oct 24, 2010

Share This Page