Football 2008 Rookie Class - Boom or Bust?

[Archangel]

With the opening of training camps and pre- season play not too far off, let's see what you think of the 2008 rookie class.
Rate your Top 5 and Bottom 5 Rookie Draft Picks for 2008 .........

BOOM............
1. Darren McFadden
2. Glenn Dorsey
3. Jacob Hester
4. Matt Ryan
5. Felix Jones

Bust...............
1. Xavier Adibi
2. Jake Long
3. Steve Slaton
4. Malcolm Kelly
5. Limas Sweed

 

[BlackCat87]

jaek long is not a bust hes gonna be the top 3 lt in the nfl

mcfadden,ryan,williams,steltz,chris long

 

[balance13]

BOOM............
1. Darren McFadden
2. Glenn Dorsey
3. Keith Rivers
4. John David Booty (if he plays)
5. Chris Long

Bust...............
1. Joe Flacco
2. Jake Long
3. Brian Brohm
4. Malcolm Kelly
5. Matt Ryan

 

[npatton]

BOOM............
1. Darren McFadden
2. Glenn Dorsey
3. Jacob Hester
4. Matt Ryan
5. Felix Jones



Bust
1. Jake Long (Seen Him Get Run Over to Many Time In Ann Arbor Slow.....)
2. Joe Flacco
3. Brian Brohm
4. Malcolm Kelly
5. Matt Ryan

 

[balance13]

lol you have ryan as a boom and a bust

 

[npatton]

i think hes gonna be good ,but not for the birds so he gets on both list

 

[Bryan_Mc]

BOOM
1.trevor laws
2.DeSean jackson
3.bryan smith
4.mike mcglynn
5.quentin demps

BUST
1.felix jones
2.mike jenkins
3.martellus bennet
4.tashard choice
5.orlando scandrick

 

[ross9013]

How can you determine who is going to boom or be a bust when none of them have yet to take a snap in the NFL...

 

[oriolesfan]

boom- dustin keller, jamal charles, aqib talib, jonathan stewart, r.mendenhall
bust- mcfadden, malcolm kelly, devin thomas, chad henne, joe flacco

 

[Bryan_Mc]

How can you determine who is going to boom or be a bust when none of them have yet to take a snap in the NFL...

purely speculation, ross